Article
Carolyn Risdale

The Day it Rained Meat

Read the totally gross, totally true story of the Kentucky meat shower.

By Mackenzie Carro and Blair Rainsford
From the May 2022 Issue
Lexiles: 530L
Guided Reading Level: M
DRA Level: 20-24
Vocabulary: common, waterspouts, tornadoes, revolting, carnivorous, investigate
Topic: Science,
Download and Print

Jim McMahon

The meat fell from the sky in Kentucky.

It was March 3, 1876, almost 150 years ago. The day was cool and clear. There wasn’t a cloud in the sky.

A woman named Mary Crouch stood in her yard. She was making homemade soap. Back then, many people made soap themselves.

Suddenly, something strange began to fall from the sky. Mary thought it looked a bit like snow. But it wasn’t cold enough for snow.

It wasn’t hail or rain either. What was happening? Mary looked up.

It was meat.

Chunks of meat were dropping from the sky.

It was March 3, 1876. The day was cool and clear. There wasn’t a cloud in the sky.

A woman named Mary Crouch stood in her yard. She was making homemade soap. Long ago, people made soap themselves.

Something strange began to fall from the sky. Mary thought it looked like snow. But it wasn’t cold.

What was happening? Mary looked up.

It was meat.

Chunks of meat were falling from the sky.

Almost 150 years ago, on March 3, 1876, the day was cool and clear. There wasn’t a cloud in the sky as a woman named Mary Crouch stood in her yard making homemade soap. Long ago, people made soap themselves.

Suddenly, something strange began to fall from the sky. Mary thought it looked a bit like snow, but it wasn’t cold enough for snow.

It wasn’t hail or rain either. What was happening? Mary looked up.

It was meat.

Chunks of meat were falling from the sky.


Raining Frogs and Fish

Raining Frogs and Fish

Raining Frogs and Fish

Johannes Kornelius/Shutterstock.com (Fish); Cristian M. Vela/Alamy Stock Photo (Turtle); Arek Rainczuk/Shutterstock.com (Frog)

Fish, turtles, and frogs have all fallen from the sky.

“Meat showers” are not common. They don’t happen that often.

But there have been many stories of odd things coming down from the sky. Two thousand years ago, someone wrote about fish and frogs falling from the sky. In the 1700s, some people said that toads fell from the clouds and landed on their hats!

Odd things have also fallen from the sky not too long ago. Hundreds of fish fell over a town in Australia just 12 years ago.

And something amazing happens every year in one town in South America. It rains fish! The town has a holiday to celebrate it.

“Meat showers” are not common. They don’t happen that often.

But there are stories of odd things falling from the sky. Two thousand years ago, someone wrote about fish and frogs falling from the sky. In 1930, a turtle fell from the sky in the U.S.

It rains fish every year in a town in South America!

“Meat showers” are rare.

But there have been many stories of odd things coming down from the sky. Two thousand years ago, someone wrote about fish and frogs falling from the sky. In the 1700s, some people said that toads fell from the clouds and landed on their hats. In 1930, a turtle fell from the sky right here in the U.S.!

Odd things have also fallen from the sky more recently. In 2005, thousands of frogs dropped onto a small town in Europe.

In 2010, hundreds of fish fell over a town in Australia, and it rains fish every year in one town in South America. The town has a holiday to celebrate it!


Julia Cumes

Wild Waterspouts

Wild Waterspouts

Wild Waterspouts

How does this happen? We know that raindrops fall from clouds high in the sky. Are there clouds of fish and frogs up in the sky too?

No. Scientists say that when these animals fall from the sky, it’s not really rain. The scientists say waterspouts make these things happen.

What are waterspouts? They are kind of like tornadoes. 

Tornadoes are winds that spin really fast over land. Waterspouts are like tornadoes, but they happen over water, not land. In a waterspout, winds spin around and around really fast over oceans and lakes. 

When those waterspout winds are spinning, they do something really cool. They suck up the water! They make a spinning tube of water over the ocean or lake. They also suck up whatever’s in the water. They are like a vacuum cleaner. 

If a waterspout is spinning over a lake full of fish, the fish can get sucked up into it. And if frogs or turtles are in the water, thwooop! They get sucked up too. 

The waterspout keeps moving until it’s over land. The winds slow down and then stop. The animals that were up in the air fall. To the people on the ground, it looks like animals are raining from the sky! 

How does this happen? We know that raindrops fall from clouds. Are there clouds of fish and frogs too?

No. Scientists say waterspouts make it happen.

Waterspouts are like tornadoes. Tornadoes happen over land. Waterspouts happen over water.

Waterspout winds spin quickly. They suck up water! They also suck up whatever’s in the water. They are like a vacuum cleaner.

If a waterspout is spinning over a lake full of fish, the fish can get sucked up into it. Frogs or turtles can get sucked up too.

The waterspout keeps moving until it’s over land. The winds slow down. Then the wind stops. The animals that were up in the air fall. It looks like animals are raining!

How does this happen? We know that raindrops fall from clouds high in the sky, but are there clouds of fish and frogs up in the sky too?

No. Scientists say that when these animals fall from the sky, it’s not really rain. The scientists say waterspouts make these things happen.

What are waterspouts? They are kind of like tornadoes. Tornadoes are winds that spin really fast over land. Waterspouts are like tornadoes, but they happen over water, not land. In a waterspout, winds spin around and around really fast over oceans and lakes. 

When those waterspout winds are spinning, they do something really cool—they suck up the water! They make a spinning tube of water over the ocean or lake. Like a vacuum cleaner, they also suck up whatever’s in the water.

If a waterspout is spinning over a lake full of fish, the fish can get sucked up into it. And if frogs or turtles are in the water, thwooop! They get sucked up too.

The waterspout keeps moving until it’s over land. The winds slow down, eventually stopping and dropping the animals that were up in the air. To the people on the ground, it looks like animals are raining from the sky! 


Vulture Vomit

Vulture Vomit

Vulture Vomit

So what happened in Kentucky back in 1876? Did a waterspout pass over a butcher shop and then spew chunks of meat all over Mary Crouch’s yard?

Nope. Scientists have a much yuckier, much more revolting reason for the meat shower.

Vomit. Vulture vomit.

Vultures are carnivorous birds. That means they eat meat. When these birds are scared, they do something gross. They throw up.

If they are scared of another animal, they can barf on that animal from 10 feet away!

What do vultures do if they get scared while they are flying? They vomit. All that meat in their stomachs spews out into the air.

Kentucky is home to two kinds of vultures. Scientists decided that Mary was in the wrong place at the wrong time. She was standing under flying, vomiting vultures!

We don’t know what the vultures might have been scared of. Maybe something surprised them. And they puked.

What happened in Kentucky back in 1876? Did a waterspout pass over a butcher shop?

Nope. Scientists have a much yuckier reason for the meat shower.

Vomit. Vulture vomit.

Vultures are carnivorous birds. That means they eat meat. They do something gross when they are scared. They throw up.

They can barf on an animal 10 feet away!

If a vulture gets scared while flying, it vomits. All that meat in its stomach goes out into the air.

Scientists think Mary was standing under flying, vomiting vultures!

We don’t know what the vultures might have been scared of. Maybe something surprised them.

So what happened in Kentucky back in 1876? Did a waterspout pass over a butcher shop and then spew chunks of meat all over Mary Crouch’s yard?

Nope—scientists have a much yuckier, much more revolting reason for the meat shower.

Vomit. Vulture vomit.

Vultures are carnivorous birds, which means they eat meat. When these birds are scared, they do something gross—they throw up.

If they are scared of another animal, they can barf on that animal from 10 feet away!

What do vultures do if they get scared while they are flying? They vomit, and all that meat in their stomachs spews out into the air.

Kentucky is home to two kinds of vultures. Scientists decided that Mary was in the wrong place at the wrong time. She was standing under flying, vomiting vultures!

We don’t know what the vultures might have been scared of—maybe something surprised them and they puked.


Marcin Mierzejewski/Shutterstock.com

This is a turkey vulture. These birds live all over the United States.

Tasting the Meat Rain

Tasting the Meat Rain

Tasting the Meat Rain

Courtesy Transylvania University

This bottle has the real meat that fell from the sky!

But wait. How do we know it was really meat that fell that day?

Someone tasted it, of course!

When Mary told others about the falling meat, two people came to investigate. They wanted to find out what was going on.

The men took a little bite of one of the chunks in the yard. They told a New York Times reporter that it tasted like “mutton or venison.” (Mutton is the meat
of a sheep, and venison is the meat of a deer.)

How do we know it was really meat that fell that day?

Someone tasted it!

When Mary told others about the falling meat, two people came to check it out.

The men took a little bite of one of the chunks. They said it tasted like meat.

But wait, how do we know it was really meat that fell that day?

Someone tasted it, of course!

When Mary told others about the falling meat, two people came to investigate.

The men took a little bite of one of the chunks in the yard. They told a New York Times reporter that it tasted like “mutton (sheep) or venison (deer).”


Luxx Images/Getty Images

People saved the meat in a bottle. No one knows for sure if the meat definitely came from vultures, but it would make a lot of sense.

After that weird March day in 1876, there were no other stories of meat rain. Mary was probably really happy about this. 

But someone else might not have been too happy about it. People said that Mary’s cat had gobbled up a lot of the meat chunks on the ground. Maybe that cat wouldn’t have minded another shower of disgusting meat! 

People saved the meat in a bottle. No one knows for sure if the meat definitely came from vultures.

After that weird day, there were no other stories of meat rain. Mary was probably really happy about this.

People said that Mary’s cat had gobbled up a lot of the meat chunks on the ground. Maybe that cat wouldn’t have minded another shower of disgusting meat! 

People saved the meat in a bottle. No one knows for sure if the meat definitely came from vultures, but it would make a lot of sense.

After that weird March day in 1876, there were no other stories of meat rain, and Mary was probably really happy about this.

But someone else might not have been too happy about it. People said that Mary’s cat had gobbled up a lot of the meat chunks on the ground. Maybe that cat wouldn’t have minded another disgusting meat shower!


video (2)
video (2)
Slideshows (1)
Activities (8)
video (2)
video (2)
Slideshows (1)
Activities (8) Download All Quizzes and Activities

More About the Article

Science Focus

Animal adaptations, Weather

Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

ESSENTIAL QUESTION

The big question of this issue of Storyworks 2 is: What makes something gross?

  • Reading and discussing “The Day It Rained Meat,” along with the other themed texts in the magazine (the Mini Read, “Wall of Gum”; the fiction piece, “House of Worms”; Word Play, “4 Ways to Say ‘Gross’”; Words & Pictures, “Worms!”; and the poetry kit, “Garbage Truck”), will help kids think about this question. 

1. BEFORE READING

NEW! Show the “Storyworks Special Report” Video (10 minutes)

Watch “Storyworks Special Report: Wild Weather”

  • This new video gives kids important background information about wild weather.  Before watching, tell kids to pay attention to the different kinds of wild weather. You’re going to ask them to name a few kinds of wild weather after watching. This will help focus kids as they watch.
  • Watch the video.
  • After watching, ask, “Can you name any kinds of wild weather?”

Preview Vocabulary (3-5 minutes)

  • Play the online vocabulary slideshow. This article’s featured words are common, waterspouts, tornadoes, revolting, carnivorous, investigate.

Preview the First Pages and Set a Purpose for Reading (5-10 minutes)

  • Now tell students they are going to read a nonfiction article. Tell them it connects to the video they watched about what makes something gross.
  • Open your magazines to “The Day It Rained Meat.” Preview the text features on the opening pages.
  • Next, read the Think and Read prompt on page 6: “As you read, think about the odd things that can fall from the sky. Do you think they are gross? Does your opinion change once you know why they fall?” Encourage students to think about this prompt as they read.

2. READ THE ARTICLE

Read Together (15-30 minutes)

  • You can read this article together as a class or in small groups.
  • Check comprehension as you read the article together with the Pause and Think questions.

3. AFTER READING

Watch “The Big Question” Video
 
“The Big Question: What Makes Something Gross?” (This video also goes with other stories in this month’s Storyworks 2.)
  • Watching this video after reading will help students delve into the essential question.
  • Before watching, ask students to pay attention to how something might be gross to one person and not gross to someone else.
  • Watch the video.
  • After watching, ask students to think about the article “The Day It Rained Meat.” What is one thing in the article that was gross to someone and not gross to someone else? (Answers could include: The meat rain was gross to Mary Crouch but not gross to her cat; it was gross to Mary Crouch but not gross to the birds who were vomiting.)

FOCUS ON ELA SKILLS

Assessment: Quiz (10 minutes)

ELA Focus: Vocabulary (20 minutes)

  • Use the Word Work printable to deepen students’ understanding of the article’s vocabulary words.

ELA Focus: Nonfiction Text Features (20 minutes)

  • This Big Read is packed with nonfiction text features such as headlines, subheads, maps, captions, and bold words. Kids can do our Nonfiction Text Feature Hunt skills page either digitally online or on a printed copy.

ELA: Prove It to Nosey (20 minutes)

  • Using the “Prove It to Nosey” printable, ask students to prove whether or not sentences are true by looking back at the text and finding evidence.

Enrich the Learning: Paired Text Opportunities (time amount varies)

Making text-to-text connections builds knowledge and comprehension. We layer Storyworks 2 with many ways for your students to make connections.

  • Kids can compare texts by using our “Gross-Out Chart” printable.

Scavenger Hunt Slide Deck (20 minutes)

  • We created a Scavenger Hunt Slide Deck for several stories in this month’s Storyworks 2, including this nonfiction piece. The scavenger hunt can be done by students independently at home or during class time.
  • This is a self-contained group of slides that guide your students on a scavenger hunt through the whole issue. It’s not only fun; it  helps them make text-to-text connections.

Text-to-Speech